Greywulf’s Guide to 4e Character Generation by Hand

You may also like...

8 Responses

  1. Chip Warden says:

    Since I’m a Mac user, Character Builder has not been an option for me. I’ve been making 4e characters “by hand” for almost 2 years. Kudos for putting this resource up on the web.

  2. OnlineDM says:

    Interesting essay. Honestly, I think it would work better without the mechanical parts of it. The interesting stuff is the way you describe the joy of creating a character based on a concept and then pulling the numbers and choices together around that concept. That’s non-system-specific and would probably be interesting to people who play other games, too.

    As for the mechanics, that’s the part where I think the essay was a little weak, actually. The point of the mechanics section in your essay was, “See, this isn’t so hard! You don’t need some computer program to do it for you!”

    Now, I’m okay with the idea of sticking to the original Player’s Handbook and ignoring almost all errata. But I struggle a little with with your decision to create a fighter. It feels like cheating to make your simple character when you go with a simple class (the race isn’t as big a deal, since you do have to choose an extra feat and at-will power with the human).

    You say that power cards aren’t necessary, and with these particular powers I agree. However, I think there are powers from other classes that would probably take up more space on your character sheet (Cloud of Daggers, Sacred Flame, Riposte Strike, Furious Smash, etc.).

    Also, if you do want to stick with the mechanics, I’d suggest throwing at least Melee Basic Attack in there, especially for a fighter with Combat Challenge and Combat Superiority.

    Useful essay!

    • greywulf says:

      I’m confused now. Did I put in too many mechanics, or not enough? :/

      I didn’t want to explicitly walk through “Add this number to your CON score to get your Hit Points”, etc because all that information is already covered in the PHB :D

      I purposefully chose a simple build to show exactly that – it’s simple to do. If I had picked a class requiring more detail (such as a Wizard), I’d just be repeating myself needlessly. the more “complex” Classes tend to only be complex in that they have more Powers to choose from in-play, that’s all.

      I don’t think there are many Powers which can’t be represented in one or two lines at most. I think we’re far too blinded by the idea of Power Cards and a layout which consumes acres of page space.

      To use your own examples (and completely making up the numbers along the way):

      Cloud of Daggers/w Area 1sq in 10,+4vRef, d6+4, plus 3 to creature that starts or ends turn there. Lasts to end of next turn

      Sacred Flame/w R5, +4vRef, d6+4 and 1 ally gains 4hp or makes a saving throw

      Riposte Strike/w +7vAC, d6+4. If attacks before start of next turn, +2vAC d6+4 as immediate interupt

      Furious Smash/w +6vAC, 4 dmg and 1 adjacent ally gets +3 to-hit and dmg against the target

      The key here is to write down only what you need on your sheet to be able to play the game. Definitions, etc can stay where they belong – in the rule book.

      Hope that helps!

  3. UHF says:

    I thought that you covered the mechanics just right…

    If you play one 4 hour D&D session a week and peel off 2 encounters per session, you’ll need character builder once every 5 weeks if that.

    One rule I use to limit over optimization of characters is to limit the maximum stats of the character to 18, that keeps the players from pursuing one shot wonders.

    Very little of the errata addresses game damaging capabilities. Cleric – Righteous Brand comes to mind, and it was also one of the first powers to be errata’d.

    I LOVE the way Essentials makes the game more paper and pencil friendly. I think its key is in how its presented, and I really wish they had presented the power books the same way, even if it was just vertical lists of powers for say a Brawler fighter.

  4. Sian says:

    Well, I’ll probably end up relying even more heavily now on the charop wiki on the wizards community site with the CB relegated to obsolescence.

  1. November 6, 2010

    […] check out this great guide to Character Generation, written by Greywulf. 2Comment [ Comments RSS […]

  2. November 9, 2010

    […] Greywulf’s Guide to 4e Character Generation by Hand, via Greywulf’s Lair. Very useful if you’ve relied on the Character Builder so far but aren’t renewing your subscription, can’t use the online tool at your gaming table, or miss the old fashioned way of doing things. […]

Leave a Reply